Types of Residential Water Heaters Compared

Share This Post

Choosing the right water heater for your home can be a daunting task. With various options available in the market, it’s essential to understand the different types of residential water heaters and their features to make an informed decision. In this article, we will explore and compare the most common types of water heaters, including the increasingly popular heat pump water heaters. So, let’s dive in!

Table of Contents

  1. Introduction: The Importance of a Reliable Water Heater
  2. Conventional Storage Water Heaters
  3. Tankless Water Heaters
  4. Heat Pump Water Heaters
  5. Comparing Energy Efficiency
  6. Comparing Cost Effectiveness
  7. Installation Considerations
  8. Maintenance Requirements
  9. Lifespan and Durability
  10. Performance and Hot Water Capacity
  11. Environmental Impact
  12. Noise Levels
  13. Rebates and Incentives
  14. Factors to Consider When Choosing a Water Heater
  15. Conclusion

1. Introduction: 

The Importance of having a reliable water heater is crucial for our daily activities, from taking warm showers to doing laundry or washing dishes. Before we delve into the different types of water heaters, it’s important to understand their significance in providing hot water efficiently and consistently. 

2. Conventional Storage Water Heaters

Conventional storage water heaters, also known as tank-type water heaters, are the most common and traditional option found in many households. They consist of a large tank that stores and heats a specific amount of water. When hot water is needed, it is delivered from the tank through the plumbing system.

Advantages:

  • They are relatively affordable and have lower upfront costs compared to other types of water heaters.
  • Conventional storage water heaters can provide hot water to multiple outlets simultaneously, making them suitable for larger households.
  • The installation process is relatively straightforward, and many plumbers are familiar with this type of water heater.

Limitations:

  • They have a limited hot water capacity based on the size of the tank. Once the hot water in the tank is depleted, it takes time for the tank to refill and heat the water.
  • Energy efficiency can be a concern, as standby heat loss can occur when the water in the tank is constantly being heated, even when not in use.
  • The size of the tank may require a considerable amount of space for installation.

3. Tankless Water Heaters

Tankless water heaters, also known as on-demand water heaters, have gained popularity due to their compact size and energy efficiency. Unlike conventional storage heaters, tankless models heat water only when there is a demand for it. They use high-powered burners or electric heating elements to heat the water instantaneously as it flows through the unit.

Advantages:

  • They provide hot water on demand, eliminating the need for a storage tank and ensuring a continuous supply of hot water.
  • Tankless water heaters are compact and take up less space, making them suitable for smaller homes or apartments.
  • They are energy-efficient since there is no standby heat loss associated with storing and constantly reheating water.
  • Tankless models have a longer lifespan compared to conventional storage water heaters.

Limitations:

  • The upfront cost of tankless water heaters is higher compared to conventional storage heaters.
  • The flow rate of hot water may be limited, depending on the size and capacity of the unit. Simultaneous use of multiple hot water outlets may affect the overall performance.
  • Installation may require upgrades to the electrical system or gas lines, depending on the type of unit.
  • Regular maintenance, such as descaling, is necessary to prevent mineral build-up and ensure optimal performance.

4. Heat Pump Water Heaters

Heat pump water heaters (HPWHs) are an innovative and energy-efficient alternative that utilizes heat from the surrounding air or ground to heat the water. This type of water heater works similarly to a refrigerator but in reverse. It extracts heat from the ambient air or ground and transfers it to the water, resulting in highly efficient water heating.

Advantages:

  • Heat pump water heaters are incredibly energy-efficient, as they extract heat from the environment rather than generating heat directly.
  • They can significantly reduce energy consumption and lower utility bills compared to conventional storage or tankless water heaters.
  • HPWHs can be used in various climates, although extreme cold temperatures may affect their performance (Lucky for us Australians, we rarely experience extreme sub zero degree temperatures).
  • They have a longer lifespan compared to conventional storage water heaters.

Limitations:

  • Heat pump water heaters generally have a higher upfront cost compared to other types of water heaters. However, the long-term energy savings can offset this initial investment.
  • They require a specific installation space with proper ventilation and sufficient ambient heat to operate efficiently.
  • HPWHs tend to have a slower recovery rate compared to tankless or conventional storage water heaters.
  • Regular maintenance, such as cleaning the air filters and checking refrigerant levels, is necessary to ensure optimal performance.

5. Comparing Energy Efficiency

Energy efficiency is a significant factor to consider when choosing a water heater. It not only reduces your environmental impact but also affects your utility bills. Let’s compare the energy efficiency of conventional storage, tankless, and heat pump water heaters:

  • Conventional Storage Water Heaters: These water heaters have lower energy efficiency due to standby heat loss, where the tank continuously heats the water even when not in use. However, newer models may come with better insulation to reduce heat loss.
  • Tankless Water Heaters: Tankless models are highly energy-efficient because they only heat water on demand. There is no standby heat loss associated with storing and reheating water. However, the flow rate and capacity of the unit can affect overall efficiency.
  • Heat Pump Water Heaters: Heat pump water heaters are the most energy-efficient option, as they utilize ambient heat from the air or ground. They can generate 2-3 times more heat energy than the electricity they consume. However, their efficiency may be affected by extreme temperatures.

6. Comparing Cost Effectiveness

In addition to energy efficiency, the cost-effectiveness of a water heater is an important consideration. Let’s analyse the upfront costs, long-term savings, and payback periods associated with conventional storage, tankless, and heat pump water heaters:

  • Conventional Storage Water Heaters: These water heaters generally have lower upfront costs compared to tankless or heat pump models. However, the long-term operating costs may be higher due to standby heat loss and less energy efficiency.
  • Tankless Water Heaters: Tankless models have higher upfront costs compared to conventional storage water heaters. However, their energy efficiency can result in long-term savings on utility bills. The payback period varies based on energy usage and the cost of fuel or electricity.
  • Heat Pump Water Heaters: Heat pump water heaters have higher upfront costs compared to both conventional storage and tankless models. However, their exceptional energy efficiency can lead to significant long-term savings. The payback period depends on factors such as energy prices and usage patterns.

7. Installation Considerations

Different water heaters have varying installation requirements. Let’s discuss the installation considerations for conventional storage, tankless, and heat pump water heaters, including space requirements, venting options, and potential challenges you may encounter during installation:

  • Conventional Storage Water Heaters: These water heaters require a dedicated space for the tank, as well as proper venting to expel combustion gases. The installation process involves connecting the plumbing and ensuring compliance with local building codes.
  • Tankless Water Heaters: Tankless models are compact and can be mounted on walls or in smaller spaces. They require proper ventilation and may need upgrades to gas lines or electrical systems. Installation complexity depends on the specific unit and its requirements.
  • Heat Pump Water Heaters: Heat pump water heaters require ample space for proper installation. They need access to ambient air or ground, and the installation area should have sufficient ventilation. Electrical considerations, such as dedicated circuits, may be necessary.

8. Maintenance Requirements

Proper maintenance ensures the longevity and optimal performance of your water heater. Let’s outline the maintenance requirements for conventional storage, tankless, and heat pump water heaters, including flushing, descaling, and general upkeep tips to keep your water heater running smoothly:

  • Conventional Storage Water Heaters: Regular maintenance for storage water heaters involves flushing the tank to remove sediment and mineral build-up. This helps maintain efficiency and prevent corrosion. It’s also important to check and replace the anode rod periodically.
  • Tankless Water Heaters: Tankless models require periodic flushing to remove mineral deposits that can hinder performance. The frequency of flushing depends on the water hardness and usage patterns. Consult the manufacturer’s guidelines for specific instructions.
  • Heat Pump Water Heaters: Maintenance for heat pump water heaters includes cleaning or replacing air filters, checking refrigerant levels, and inspecting the compressor and fan. Regular maintenance ensures efficient operation and extends the lifespan of the unit.

9. Lifespan and Durability

The lifespan and durability of a water heater are important factors to consider, as they impact long-term costs and reliability. Let’s compare the lifespan and durability of conventional storage, tankless, and heat pump water heaters:

  • Conventional Storage Water Heaters: On average, storage water heaters have a lifespan of 5-10 years. However, the lifespan can be shorter if not properly maintained or if the tank is exposed to corrosive elements.
  • Tankless Water Heaters: Tankless models generally have a longer life expectancy of 20+ years with the average lifespan being 10-15 years. The absence of a storage tank minimizes the risk of leaks or tank-related issues, contributing to their durability.
  • Heat Pump Water Heaters: Heat pump water heaters have a life expectancy of 25+ years with the average lifespan being around 20 years. Their durability is influenced by factors such as the quality of components, proper maintenance, and protection from environmental factors.

Expanding on these points provides a more detailed comparison of the different types of water heaters, their benefits, limitations, and considerations for making an informed decision.

10. Performance and Hot Water Capacity

The performance and hot water capacity of a water heater are crucial considerations, especially for larger households or commercial applications. Let’s delve deeper into the performance factors to compare when choosing between conventional storage, tankless, and heat pump water heaters, helping you determine the ideal option for your specific needs.

  • Conventional Storage Water Heaters: The hot water capacity of storage water heaters is determined by the size of the tank, typically ranging from 50 to 300 Litres. Larger tanks can provide a higher volume of hot water but may take longer to recover. The recovery time refers to the duration required for the tank to heat a new batch of water once the existing supply is depleted.
  • Tankless Water Heaters: Tankless models can provide a continuous supply of hot water as long as the demand does not exceed the unit’s maximum flow rate. The flow rate is measured in litres per minute (LPM) and varies depending on the model. It’s essential to choose a tankless water heater that matches the hot water demand of your household to ensure optimal performance.
  • Heat Pump Water Heaters: Heat pump water heaters have a hot water capacity similar to conventional storage water heaters, ranging from 50 to 300 litres. However, their recovery time may be longer due to the heating process that relies on extracting heat from the surrounding air or ground. It’s important to consider the specific hot water needs of your household to ensure sufficient capacity.

When comparing performance, consider factors such as the number of occupants, simultaneous hot water usage, and peak demand times. This evaluation will help you choose a water heater that can meet your household’s hot water needs effectively.

11. Environmental Impact

Considering the environmental impact of your water heater is increasingly important in today’s eco-conscious world. Let’s examine the environmental aspects of conventional storage, tankless, and heat pump water heaters, including their carbon footprint and potential for reducing greenhouse gas emissions.

  • Conventional Storage Water Heaters: Traditional storage water heaters tend to have a higher carbon footprint due to standby heat loss and higher energy consumption. However, advancements in insulation technology have improved their energy efficiency, reducing their environmental impact to some extent.
  • Tankless Water Heaters: Tankless models are considered more environmentally friendly than conventional storage water heaters due to their energy efficiency. By heating water on demand and eliminating standby heat loss, they help reduce energy consumption and greenhouse gas emissions associated with water heating.
  • Heat Pump Water Heaters: Heat pump water heaters are among the most environmentally friendly options. They operate by extracting heat from the surrounding air or ground, significantly reducing energy consumption and carbon emissions. By utilizing renewable heat sources, they contribute to a greener and more sustainable approach to water heating.

Choosing an energy-efficient water heater, such as a tankless or heat pump model, can make a significant difference in reducing your carbon footprint and promoting environmental sustainability.

12. Noise Levels

The noise produced by a water heater can be a concern, particularly if it’s installed near living spaces or bedrooms. Let’s compare the noise levels generated by conventional storage, tankless, and heat pump water heaters, allowing you to make an informed decision based on your noise sensitivity.

  • Conventional Storage Water Heaters: These water heaters typically produce minimal noise during operation. The primary sound comes from the burner or heating elements heating the water inside the tank. Once the water reaches the desired temperature, the unit remains relatively quiet until the tank reheats.
  • Tankless Water Heaters: Tankless models generally operate quietly, as there are no storage tanks or constantly running components. However, some units may produce a low humming sound when the heating elements or burner is active. The noise level is usually minimal and often not disruptive.
  • Heat Pump Water Heaters: Heat pump water heaters generate noise similar to air conditioning units or refrigerators. The sound mainly comes from the fan and compressor, which are responsible for extracting heat from the ambient air or ground. While the noise level is generally tolerable, it’s advisable to consider the installation location to minimize any potential disturbance.

When choosing a water heater, take into account the proximity to living spaces, your sensitivity to noise, and the noise tolerance level of your household members.

13. Rebates and Incentives

Many states in Australia offer rebates and incentives to promote the adoption of energy-efficient water heaters. In order to receive accurate rebate amounts (as they are constantly changing) it’s best to contact installers and ask. As a general rule of thumb electric storage systems receive the most rebates, followed by gas storage systems and other types of heaters. 

14. Aesthetics and Design

The aesthetics and design of a water heater may be a consideration, especially if it’s visible in your living space. Let’s explore the visual aspects of conventional storage, tankless, and heat pump water heaters, helping you find a water heater that complements your home’s interior and meets your aesthetic preferences.

  • Conventional Storage Water Heaters: These water heaters are typically large tanks that require dedicated space. They may be less visually appealing since they are not designed to be a focal point. However, newer models often come with improved aesthetics, such as sleeker designs or better insulation, making them less obtrusive.
  • Tankless Water Heaters: Tankless models have a compact and wall-mounted design, taking up less space and providing more flexibility in terms of installation. Their small size and streamlined appearance can blend well with modern interiors or utility spaces.
  • Heat Pump Water Heaters: Heat pump models are larger in size compared to tankless units but still offer a more compact design compared to conventional storage water heaters. While aesthetics may be less of a focus, some manufacturers offer heat pump water heaters with visually appealing enclosures.

Consider your preferences for the visibility and integration of the water heater within your home’s design when choosing the best option for your specific requirements.

Expanding on these points provides a comprehensive overview of the various factors involved in comparing different types of residential water heaters.

15. Conclusion

In conclusion, selecting the right water heater is crucial for ensuring a consistent supply of hot water while considering energy efficiency, cost-effectiveness, installation requirements, maintenance, lifespan, performance, and environmental impact. By comparing conventional storage, tankless, and heat pump water heaters, you can make an informed decision that meets your specific needs.

FAQs (Frequently Asked Questions)

1. Are heat pump water heaters suitable for all climates?

Heat pump water heaters are generally suitable for various climates. However, extreme cold temperatures may affect their performance and efficiency. In Victoria, heat pump water heaters should work year-round in all suburbs.  

2. Do tankless water heaters provide instant hot water?

While tankless water heaters provide hot water on demand, there may be a slight delay before the hot water reaches the tap. Factors such as the distance from the heater to the tap and the flow rate can affect the time taken for hot water delivery.

3. Can I replace my conventional storage water heater with a heat pump water heater? Yes, you can replace your conventional storage water heater with a heat pump water heater. However, it’s important to consider the installation requirements, including space, ventilation, and electrical considerations, as heat pump water heaters have specific needs.

4. Which type of water heater is the most cost-effective in the long run?

The cost-effectiveness of a water heater depends on various factors, including energy prices, usage patterns, and initial investment. Generally, heat pump water heaters offer long-term cost savings due to their high energy efficiency, although the upfront cost may be higher than conventional storage water heaters.

5. Are heat pump water heaters noisy?

Heat pump water heaters tend to generate some noise due to the compressor and fan operation. However, newer models are designed with noise reduction features, making them relatively quieter than older units. The noise levels can vary, so it’s advisable to check the manufacturer’s specifications and customer reviews.

With this comprehensive guide to residential water heaters, including a detailed comparison of conventional storage, tankless, and heat pump water heaters, you can now make an informed decision based on your specific needs, budget, and preferences. Remember to consider factors such as energy efficiency, cost-effectiveness, installation requirements, and environmental impact to choose the ideal water heater that provides reliable hot water while minimizing both your utility bills and carbon footprint.

More
articles